Check out what critics are saying about Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s play, currently performing until the 18th May.
The Guardian: *** “Even with its off notes, The Comeuppance is good theatre with eloquent outbursts and awkward wit. Its themes play in the mind after the curtain comes down and it is a relief to see theatre dealing with the Covid years, staring its death in the face.”
Time Out: *** “It’s a sidelong look at ageing, at its heart underpinned by a wry amusement at the very idea of millennials getting old. And the fact Jacobs-Jenkins doesn’t feel like the sort of playwright who writes a play about this sort of thing is precisely what makes ‘The Comeuppance’ so compelling.”
Evening Standard: *** “Despite occasional extreme reactions to truthtelling, characters change too little to ultimately make us care. And while the presence of death adds intellectual perspective, only in the final coda does it do anything to propel real drama.”
The Arts Desk: *** “Originally staged Off-Broadway last summer, the play has been brought to Islington’s Almeida Theatre by its original director, Eric Ting, with a new and excellent British cast. As well as being a reunion play, it’s also a memory play with ghostly elements. Question is, does this mix work on stage?”
All That Dazzles: ***** “Eric Ting’s direction matches the brilliance of Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’ writing effortlessly, particularly in his approach of having actors transform from their own characters into Death throughout the play.”
Everything Theatre: **** “Branden Jacobs-Jenkins has written a thought-provoking show which successfully taps into universal fears, yet somehow reassures us at the same time.”
The Independent: *** “Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s production is rich in ideas and beautifully staged, but it’s still two hours of listening to middle-aged millennials feeling sorry for themselves.”
The Telegraph: *** “The usually dazzling writer Branden Jacobs-Jenkins doesn’t quite land his mark with this tense play about an awkward school reunion.”
WhatsOnStage: **** “Director Eric Ting holds the multiple shifts in tone, sometimes in the turn of sentence, in a strong grip, letting events unspool realistically over an unbroken two hours, but also allowing the sense of the numinous, of the unspoken, to creep through the text.”
Culture Whisper: **** “Bitingly funny and abruptly sad, this momentary portrait of five people trapped inside their own decisions is a reminder life is fragile and temporary.”
The Stage: *** “Eerie drama of mortality and memory from Branden Jacobs-Jenkins exerts an insidious fascination.”
West End Best Friend: *** “Director Eric Ting has done wonderfully in bringing this text to life though, what is good in the script is made all the better for the show’s direction and helped in turn by the cast’s entertaining ensemble performance, with each of its members just as solid as the last’s. Arnulfo Maldonado’s black void of a backdrop allows his front porch to become the true focal point pf the show and Emma Laxton’s sound design adds a brilliantly creepy and unsettling edge to Death’s presence in the piece. Overall, the play is solid as a piece of theatre, yet its lack of a truly satisfying conclusion prevents it from standing out above the rest and making as big a mark that it perhaps could have.”
Broadway World: **** “School reunion stories have been done before, but this one does something a little different – and as well as all that, it broaches the trauma of the COVID pandemic in an original and thought-provoking way. Entertaining yet hard-hitting, this is very much worth two hours of your time.”
There Ought to be Clowns: “Ultimately though, not a lot actually happens. Death turns out to be all talk and no trousers and for all that this group has gone through, too little comes of it to merit the two-hours-straight-through of the production. Despite this, Anthony Welsh and Tamara Lawrance are good, with Ferdinand Kingsley making a real impact alongside Yolanda Kettle and Katie Leung, but since Death speaks with a reverb and a whole scene is delivered through a mobile phone, there’s some serious audibility issues which further detract from the whole shebang.”
The Reviews Hub: **** “Death may ultimately view that period through rose-tinted glasses – just listen to the the second series of Jon Ronson’s Things Fall Apart on BBC Sounds to remember the culture wars that erupted during the pandemic – but the end of the play is almost Chekhovian in nature as it gestures to the inexorable. Who knows if this play will be revived in years to come, but for now, in 2024, it seems very important.”
To book tickets visit: https://almeida.co.uk/whats-on/the-comeuppance/
